Managed Nebula vs Cloudflare Tunnel

Last updated:

Abstract purple and blue gradient

Managed Nebula and Cloudflare Tunnel take very different approaches to secure connectivity. Nebula creates a peer-to-peer mesh network where hosts communicate directly. Cloudflare Tunnel routes traffic through Cloudflare’s global network, acting as a reverse proxy for your services.

Nebula is a fully open-source overlay networking tool that we originally built at Slack and continue to maintain at Defined Networking. It uses its own protocol built on the Noise framework to create peer-to-peer encrypted tunnels between hosts. Managed Nebula is our cloud-hosted management layer that handles certificate authorities, host configuration, and distribution, while your traffic stays encrypted end-to-end between your hosts.

Cloudflare Tunnel (formerly Argo Tunnel) creates outbound-only connections from your infrastructure to Cloudflare’s edge network. Remote users access your services through Cloudflare’s proxy, authenticated via Cloudflare Access (their zero-trust platform).

Below, we break down the key differences to help you decide which is right for your network.

Managed Nebula Cloudflare Tunnel
Architecture Peer-to-peer mesh Proxy through Cloudflare edge
Traffic path Direct host-to-host Through Cloudflare’s network
Authentication Certificate-based (Nebula CA) Identity provider via Access
Firewall Stateful with security groups Cloudflare Access policies
Protocol Nebula (Noise IX) QUIC/HTTP2 to Cloudflare edge
Open source Fully (MIT license) Client open-source; edge closed
Data path Encrypted end-to-end Cloudflare processes traffic
Free tier Up to 100 hosts Zero Trust free up to 50 users
Pricing $1/host/month Free tunnels; Access is per-seat

These tools solve connectivity in fundamentally different ways.

Nebula creates a mesh network where hosts communicate directly with each other through encrypted peer-to-peer tunnels. Traffic between two hosts takes the most direct network path. Your data is encrypted end-to-end between hosts, so no third party can read it, even when a connection has to go through a relay. The network is fully decentralized: if our control plane goes offline, your existing network continues operating normally.

Cloudflare Tunnel creates outbound connections from your servers to Cloudflare’s edge network. When a user accesses a service, their request goes to Cloudflare’s nearest edge location, through the tunnel to your origin server, and back. Cloudflare sits in the middle of every connection, which means your traffic passes through their infrastructure. This is by design: Cloudflare provides DDoS protection, WAF, and caching at the edge.

Nebula has a stateful packet firewall built directly into the Nebula process. Firewall rules reference groups embedded in certificates, working similarly to AWS Security Groups. Access control is distributed and enforced on every host, not dependent on a central service.

Cloudflare Access provides identity-aware access control through Cloudflare’s edge. Policies are defined in the Cloudflare dashboard and enforce authentication via identity providers (Okta, Google, Azure AD, etc.) before allowing access to tunneled services. This is a zero-trust model where Cloudflare’s edge is the policy enforcement point.

With Managed Nebula you get to choose: the simple reliability of Defined-hosted discovery and relay infrastructure, data sovereignty through running your entire data plane with self-hosted lighthouses and relays, or maximum redundancy enabled by mixing the two approaches. Either way, traffic is encrypted end-to-end between your hosts. A relay can forward packets but cannot read or alter them, and we never terminate or inspect your traffic. Our lighthouses and relays operate independently of our management service, so if it experiences downtime, your overlay network keeps working.

With Cloudflare Tunnel, all traffic passes through Cloudflare’s global network. Cloudflare can see request metadata and, depending on your configuration, may terminate TLS and inspect traffic for WAF and caching purposes. You are dependent on Cloudflare’s infrastructure for connectivity. If Cloudflare experiences an outage, your tunneled services become unreachable.

Nebula is fully open-source under the MIT license. Every component is available for inspection, modification, and self-hosting. You can run a complete Nebula network with zero dependency on us.

Cloudflare Tunnel’s client (cloudflared) is open-source, but the edge network, Access platform, and all traffic processing infrastructure are proprietary. There is no way to self-host the Cloudflare edge.

Managed Nebula offers simple per-host pricing:

  • Free: Up to 100 hosts, 2 routes, SSO, and a simple management UI. No credit card required.
  • Pro: $1/host/month with unlimited hosts, up to 100 routes, priority support, and guaranteed uptime
  • Enterprise: Custom pricing with a dedicated Slack support channel and network design assistance

See our pricing page for full details, or contact sales for Enterprise.

Cloudflare Tunnel is free to create, and Cloudflare’s Zero Trust plan, which includes Access, is free for up to 50 users. Larger teams pay per user, starting at $7 per user per month. Additional Cloudflare services (WAF, DDoS protection, etc.) have their own pricing.

Choose Managed Nebula if you want:

  • Direct host-to-host connectivity, encrypted end-to-end so no third party can read it
  • Full control over your network infrastructure and traffic routing
  • A fully open-source foundation with no proprietary dependencies
  • Certificate-based authentication with group-based firewall rules
  • A network that keeps working even if the management plane goes down

Choose Cloudflare Tunnel if you want:

  • DDoS protection and WAF at the edge for public-facing services
  • Identity provider-based zero-trust access for web applications
  • Cloudflare’s global network for caching and performance optimization
  • Outbound-only connections that don’t require opening inbound ports

Frequently asked questions

Does Nebula route traffic through a third party like Cloudflare?

Not the way Cloudflare does. Nebula creates direct peer-to-peer connections between hosts, encrypted end-to-end. When two hosts can't connect directly, a relay forwards their packets but can't read or alter them, and you can run your own relays if you'd rather no traffic touch Defined Networking's infrastructure.

Can Nebula provide DDoS protection like Cloudflare?

Nebula is a mesh networking tool, not an edge proxy. If you need DDoS protection for public-facing services, Cloudflare Tunnel is designed for that. Nebula is designed for private host-to-host connectivity.

What happens if Cloudflare goes down vs if Managed Nebula goes down?

If Cloudflare goes down, your tunneled services become unreachable. If Managed Nebula's control plane goes down, your existing network continues operating normally because the data plane is fully decentralized.


Related comparisons

Encryption that works

Fast, secure overlay networking with unlimited scalability. Up to 100 hosts free, no credit card required.

Get started